Analisis Kritik Kamil Musthafa Al-Siba’i terhadap Kitab Fajr Al-Islam Karya Ahmad Amin
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.64810/annuha.v12i2.889Keywords:
Kamil Musthafa al-Siba’i, Ahmad Amin, Fajr al-Islam, Critique of HadithAbstract
This study discusses how Kamil Musthafa al-Siba’i criticizes Ahmad Amin's book Fajr al-Islam, particularly regarding Amin's views on the emergence of fabricated hadiths and the prohibition of writing hadiths during the Prophet's time. In general, this study aims to explain the differences in perspective between the two figures, as well as to assess the basis of the arguments used by each. The method employed is a literature review by examining the book Fajr al-Islam, al-Siba’i's writings, and other supporting literature. The analysis is conducted by comparing Amin's more textual opinions with al-Siba’i's explanations, which are more contextual and historical. The results of the study show that al-Siba’i considers some of Amin's understandings of hadith to be inaccurate, especially when Amin concludes that the fabrication of hadiths had already occurred during the Prophet's time and when he interprets the prohibition of writing hadiths in an absolute manner. Al-Siba’i emphasized that the prohibition was temporary and aimed at preventing confusion in the writing of the Qur’anic revelation. Al-Siba’i’s critique shows that understanding hadith requires a more comprehensive approach, taking into account the social and historical context, not just the text alone. This study highlights the importance of critical analysis in examining the works of modern Muslim thinkers to ensure an accurate and balanced understanding of Islamic sources.
Downloads
References
Abdillah, Faisal Ridho, Muhammad Lutfi, Khoirul Amru, and Ahmad Zaidanil Kamil. “Musthafa Al-Siba’i and Islamic Socialism: Rejecting Western Idieologies and Promoting Social Solidarity.” Jurnal Tasawuf dan Pemikiran Islam 13, no. 2 (2023): 307–336.
Al-Siba’I, Musthafa. Sunah Dan Peranannya Dalam Penetapan Hukum Islam. Jakarta: Pustaka Firdaus, 1991.
Alfatih, Muhammad Amru, Farhan Rafif Satria Bakri, and Zikri Darussamin. “Perkembangan Hadits Pada Masa Kontemporer Dan Era Digital.” Jurnal Ilmu Hadis 3, no. 2 (2024): 14–29.
Amin, Ahmad. Fajrul Al-Islam Awal Mula Islam Sejarah Arab Pra Islam, Pengaruh Yahudi, Nasrani & Bangsa Non-Arab, Mentalitas Bangsa Arab, Munculnya Aliran-Aliran Islam. Depok: Keira, 2023.
Anam, Wahidul. “Encounter between the Prophet’s Sunna and the Society Tradition: A Study of Living Sunna in Puncu Sub-District, Kediri District.” Addin 14, no. 1 (2020): 1.
As, Khodijah Firdaus, Nisa Hendiyanti, and Azis Arifin. “Analisis Kritik Muhammad Musthafa As-Siba’iy Terhadap Pemikiran Ahmad Amin.” Jurnal Tafsir, Hadis dan Teologi 4, no. 2 (2024): 27–36.
Asari, Hasan. Sejarah Islam Modern Agama Dalam Negosiasi Historis Sejak Abad XIX. Medan: Perdana Publishing, 2019.
Candra, Helmi, Ahmad Fauzi, Achmad Ghozali, and Muhammad Asriady. “Kritik Mustafa Al- Siba ’ i Terhadap Ahmad Amin Tentang Keabsahan Hadis.” Journal of Shariah and Islamic Economics 2, no. 2 (2021): 44–58.
Damanik, Muhammad Zein, Dini Yuliani, Dwi Ananta Aura Ningrum, and Dea Novita. “Modernisasi Dan Sekularisasi Pemikiran Islam Di Indonesia.” At-Tabayyun: Jurnal Hukum, Ekonomi dan Pendidikan Islam 6, no. 2 (2023): 83–93.
Elnakep, Mohamed, Paolo Branca, and Shalabi Elgeidi. “The Ideology of Reform and Historical Criticism Between Secular Islamic Thought and Fundamentalist Islamic Thought ( Ahmad Amin , and Sayyid Qutb ) Model.” Jurnal Filsafat Internasional 12, no. 4 (2024): 89–96.
Fikri, Shofil, Fiimaratus Sholihah, Jasminta Murawah Hayyu, Alqodhi Adlantama, Muhammad Hanan, and Ali. “Memahami Makna Dari Hadis Dan Ilmu Hadis Menurut Pandangan Muhadditsin Dan Ushuliyyin.” Jurnal Pendidikan Islam 1, no. 4 (2024): 1–12.
Gharbal, Muhammad Syafiq. Al-Mausu’ah Al-‘Arabiyyah Al-Muyassarah. Beirut: Maktabah al-‘Ashriyyah, 2010.
Hasbullah, Abdur Rouf. “Pergolakan Hadits Kaum Modernis: Studi Komperatif Pemikiran Abu Royyah, Ahmad Amin, Dan Musthafa Al-Siba’i.” Jurnal Ilmu Hukum 2, no. 1 (2023): 2023.
Ismail, Mohd Hatib, Ahmad Sunawari Long, and Siti Rohani Jasni. “Sosialisme Islam Menurut Mustafa Al- Siba ‘ i ( Islamic Sosialisme According to Mustafa Al- Siba ‘ I ).” Journal of Revealed Knowledge 5, no. 2 (2024): 115–131.
Khan, Waqas. “Analysis of Ahmad Amin Misri Objections on Abu Hurairah ( RA ).” Jurnal Penelitian Alorooba 2, no. June (2023): 2710–5180.
Kulinich, Alena. “Memories of Tomorrow : The Modern Relevance of the Mu ‘ Tazilah in the Writings of A ḥ Mad Am ī n ( 1886 – 1954 ).” Jurnal Asia 12, no. 1 (2022): 101–130.
Kurniawan, M. Agus. “Islam Dan Modernitas Menelusuri Hubungan Antara Tradisi Dan Inovasi.” al Akmal : Jurnal Studi Islam 03, no. 06 (2024).
Lexy J. Moleong. Metodologi Penelitian Kualitatif. PT. REMAJA ROSDAKARYA,. Bandung, 2016.
Nurfadillah, Abdurrahim Supardi Usman, Muhammad Zain, Jihan Fahira, and Bahaking Rama. “Pemikiran Modern Dalam Konteks Islam Global.” Jurnal Penelitian Ilmu-Ilmu Sosial 2, no. 10 (2025).
Rahim, Zati Nazifah Binti Abdul. “Mustafa Al-Siba’i and His Perspectives About the Authority of A Hadith Based on His Book Al-Sunnah Wa- Makanatuha Fi Al- Tashir’ Al- Islami.” Jurnal of Hadith Studies 8, no. 2 (2023): 11–18.
Rahma, Devi, Anggi Fatrisia, Muhammad Jamil, Nabila Yunita, and Siti Ardianti. “Studi Komperatif Musthafa As-Siba’i Dengan Ahmad Amin Tentang Kesahihan Hadis.” Jurnal Kajian Agama dan Dakwah 2, no. 1 (2023).
Rahmah, Devi, Anggi Fatrisia, Muhammad Jamil, Nabila Yunita, and Siti Ardianti. “Studi Komperatif Musthafa As-Siba’i Dengan Ahmad Amin Tentang Kesahihan Hadis.” Jurnal Kajian Agama dan Dakwah 2, no. 1 (2023): 3030–8917.
Silaen, Putri Alisia, Khoirul Huda, Lolo Ate Berutu Karina, and Muhammad Albani. “Modernisasi Dan Sekularasi Pemikiran Islam Di Indonesia.” Metta: Jurnal Ilmu Multidisiplin 4, no. 2 (2024): 92–105.
Siregar, Ilham Ramadan, Sulidar, and Ardiansyah. “Kritik Sejarah Terhadap Hadist Menurut Ahmad Amin Analisis Terhadap Kitab Fajr Al-Islam.” Journal of Hadith Studies 1, no. 1 (2017): 50–64.
Soebahar, M. Erfan. Menguak Keabsahan As-Sunnah. Jakarta: Prenada Media, 2003.
Soraya, Nyayu, Maryamah, and Maryam. Historiografi Islam Dan Perkembangannya. Banten: PT. Desanta Muliavisitama, 2021.
Wijaya, Roma. “Pemikiran Hadis Mustafa Al-Siba’i.” Kuliah Islam 1, no. 3 (2024): 117–131.
Zifamina, M Ikhbar Fiamrillah, and Waluyo. “Dialektika Moral (Etika) Barat Dan Islam.” Journal of Multidisciplinary Islamic Studies 2, no. 1 (2025): 84–109.
Zulkifli, Tungga Bhimadi Karyasa, Lenawati Asry, Muh. Arif, Najmuddin Petta Solong, Munirah, Arditya Prayogi, and Siyono. Pemikiran Islam Modern Dalam Islam. Padang: PT Global Eksekutif Teknologi, 2023.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Normala Rista Wike Umami
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright Notice
Seluruh materi yang terdapat dalam situs ini dilindungi oleh undang-undang. Dilarang mengutip sebagian atau seluruh isi situs web ini untuk keperluan komersil tanpa persetujuan dewan penyunting jurnal ini.
Apabila anda menemukan satu atau beberapa artikel yang terdapat dalam An Nuha yang melanggar atau berpotensi melanggar hak cipta yang anda miliki, silahkan laporkan kepada kami, melalui email pada Priciple Contact.
Aspek legal formal terhadap akses setiap informasi dan artikel yang tercantum dalam situs jurnal ini mengacu pada ketentuan lisensi Creative Commons Atributs Share Alike (CC BY-SA).
Semua Informasi yang terdapat di An-NUHA bersifat akademik. An-NUHA tidak bertanggung jawab terhadap kerugian yang terjadi karana penyalah gunaan informasi dari situs ini.
